Bible Study from Calvary Chapel Newberg

with Tom Fuller

1

Honor Amidst Evil

2 Samuel 2:12-3:39

This is a perilous time for Israel. Saul is dead and David has become king in Hebron over Judah. Abner, Saul?s cousin and military commander, puts Saul?s son Ish-bosheth in as king over Benjamin and the rest of Israel. But the real power behind the throne is Abner, who no doubt was a perfect commander for Saul as a ruthless power grabber.

 

As I suggested last time, it is quite within Abner?s character to have spirited the weak Ish-bosheth away from the battle where Saul and Jonathan died, knowing that Saul was done for and wanting to keep his options open. Just as it was always about Saul, it is all about Abner.

 

On the other side, David?s military commander, his nephew Joab, is consumed with hatred and revenge. The two of them make quite a pair, wrestling to see who can put David in power and who can get the most power for themselves. Through it all we have David?the only man God has chosen to be king of Israel, who acts with honor, letting God do His work, and not falling for the machinations of man?s ego.

 

Chapter 2

 

12 ? 17

 

Mahanaim was where Abner put Ish-bosheth into power. They travel south back to the Gibeon, which is just north of Jerusalem in Benjamin. Sometimes outright battle wasn?t how armies fought. Sometimes champions would fight instead (remember Goliath in 1 Samuel 17?). This turns out to be a rather arrogant idea of Abner?s but in this case all the men kill each other!

 

Helkath-hazzurim means ?field of sword edges.? So after that little contest all out battle breaks out and Abner is defeated.

 

18 ? 23

 

Asahel was fast but not smart. Abner was a battle trained warrior. Just as Asahel caught up to Abner he turned, or just stopped quickly and Asahel got the butt of Abner?s spear right through him.

 

24 ? 28

 

Abner is no slouch. He knows he is beat so he calls a truce, even though he is the one that started it in the first place by not recognizing David as king, by putting Ish-bosheth in place and then by instigating the battle in verse 14. Joab knows the heart of his uncle David, of peace, not war, so he calls off the troops.

 

29 ? 32

 

No doubt Joab and Abishai start plotting how they might get back at Abner as they bury their brother.

 

Chapter 3

 

1

 

This shouldn?t be a surprise, as God had torn the kingdom from the house of Saul and given it to David. But you notice He doesn?t just come in and supernaturally change things here. God is letting the true nature of the leaders here come out. He will use tragedy born of ambition and treachery to reveal godly character (in David) and ambition in Abner.

 

2 ? 5

 

David continues his polygamy. Amnon would be killed by the men of Absolom. Kileab may have died before he could become David?s successor (he?s mentioned only here), Adonijah plays a key part in the story of David passing the kingdom to Solomon in 1 Kings 1-2.

 

Next, we see Abner?s real motives revealed.

 

6 ? 11

 

Abner was really trying to get the throne for himself. When a man would lie with the king?s concubine, it was an attempt for the throne (Absolom did it to David?s concubines in 16:22). When the weak Ish-bosheth questions him, Abner realizes that plan won?t work, so he decides he has the power to defeat Ish-bosheth by turning over the power of the kingdom to David, hoping that he?ll win so many points with David that he?ll be as powerful there as with Ish.

 

8 ? Abner acts like he has been so loyal to the house of Saul (?Am I a dog?s head of Judah??) but now that he is being questioned, he is fully capable of defecting. The ambitious are loyal only so long as it serves their interests. Be wary of those that appear loyal to you, but not loyal to Yahweh.

 

12 ? 13

 

A bit of shuttle diplomacy happens here. Abner may be saying ?the land is mine to give? if David makes an agreement with Abner. In reality it should have meant ?the land is yours because God gave it to you.?

 

David agrees but only if ?Saul?s daughter? Michal, his wife, is returned to him. In 1 Samuel 25 she was given wrongfully to Paltiel. But notice how David refers to her when sending the demand to Ish-bosheth.

 

14 ? 16

 

?Give me my wife? he says. It would have been Ish-bostheth?s responsibility to do this, since his father had died. He surely knew this would strengthen David?s claim to the throne (even more than Abner going into the concubine). He is powerless and so relents.

 

17 ? 21

 

Abner set up Ish as king by convincing the elders of Israel. Now, suddenly, he is quoting the Lord and claiming David should be king. The part about delivering from the Philistines is from 1 Samuel 9:16. He then goes to the Benjamites, where Saul came from.

 

Abner finally meets with David who accepts Abner?s offer to help unite the kingdom. No matter what motives Abner has here, the end result is what the Lord wants. Sometimes God allows the flesh to have its way (bringing about death in the individual) but brings about His will as a result.

 

22 ? 25

 

It is somewhat understandable that Joab would be upset with Abner, for killing his brother Asahel. But notice the arrogant tone he takes with David. Revenge is motivating his heart, and he is not after God?s will, but his own vengeance so he invents bad motives for Abner possibly as a way to justify what he is about to do.

 

26 ? 30

 

No doubt Joab purported to Abner that there was some important piece of state business that needed to be attended to. Abner is caught off guard (which is unusual), but perhaps though he is ambitious, he trusts David and comes back based on his belief that the king is behind the message.

 

In reality it is simply Joab wanting to take revenge, which he does by killing Abner in the same way that Abner killed Ahahel, in the stomach.

 

David reacts by declaring the blame resides on Joab and his household. The curse he invokes involves disease (?holds a spindle? can mean ?leans on a crutch?), which the last two involve war and famine.

 

Joab and Abishai were relying on the concept of the blood feud, that is, the kinsmen of the murdered should take revenge by killing the murderer. The only problem is that Asahel was killed in a time of war, whereas no war existed when Abner is killed.

 

So now look how David reacts, and this is key:

 

31 ? 39

 

David mourns, weeps, fasts, and declares a memorial for the fallen. Sound like how he acted when Saul and Jonathan died? Some might think that David was just a cry baby, always weeping and mourning when he should be celebrating that the man who set up his rival was now dead.

 

The only cry baby in these chapters is Paltiel. David reacts with true feelings. Though Abner was a pretender he was accepted by David, David wished him no harm and his reaction shows that he was truly out of the loop when it came to this plot.

 

This becomes vital in how David is perceived by the northern tribes. The obvious reaction is that David plotted to have him assassinated, but his mourning proves that wasn?t the case and is a key element in cementing the kingdom under David?s rule.

 

Did David plan it this way? No. He was simply acting in character of a man after God?s own heart, but God used it to bring together a nation. Don?t be afraid of thinking and feeling like God, even you appear weak (not weak in righteousness, of course).

 

David was a mighty warrior who was not afraid to have emotions and express deep feelings. Don?t be a Christian statue. Let life affect? you in the Lord.

 

Lessons

 

In many ways these chapters are about manipulation.

 

Ambition ? leads Abner to manipulate Ish-bosheth, and to try to manipulate David

 

Revenge ? leads Joab to manipulate the truth and Abner to his death (probably jealously as well?worry that Abner might take his place)

 

David, on the other hand, in this chapter acts only to move in ways already revealed to him by the Lord. He wants his wife back, he wants peace in the land under his rule, and he wants men to act righteously.

 

What do we learn about David?s character that we can apply to our own lives?

 

David took people at their word

When Abner said he was going to work with David, David believed him.

 

David trusted people until they proved otherwise

Joab was a trusted commander until he deceived Abner and murdered him in cold blood.

 

David was not afraid to call out unrighteousness

Ish-bosheth noted Abner?s treason but did nothing about it. David very publicly rebukes Joab. Now I?m saying that we need to get on the roof and shout out everyone?s sins but he also didn?t gloss over it. And if someone is in open sin and also acting in spiritual leadership or teaching wrong doctrine we shouldn?t gloss over it either.

 

David was also a realist.

He knew he was not strong enough to take on Joab and his brothers directly and kick them out of leadership. He instead relied on God for vindication and hoped for Joab?s rehabilitation. He did remain David?s commander for many years and even obeyed David in taking a census of the people despite his objections (1 Chronicles 21).